Posted by: justenjoyhim | May 9, 2008

Mother’s Day from a pragmatist’s view

I was all set to write about how we don’t do much on Mother’s day, how my first Mother’s Day I felt that Frank didn’t do “enough” to celebrate it for me and I had a hissy fit but one of the next two Mother’s Days, I got over myself. I was going to say how I don’t like the fuss people make over it because it’s hurtful to some people, adult and child alike — first mothers, mothers of loss in many ways, children (adult and non-adult) of loss in many ways. That holidays like this — including Valentine’s Day — just seem to magnify the loss of people who aren’t included in the celebrations.

I was all ready to write all of that, but then my sweet boy, covered in dirt practically from head to toe, came in the door with a white gift bag, his name on it, and a poem dedicated to mothers on it. Obviously they had worked on this at school today. Inside of it was a picture of Nate with a frame that he made, obviously with the teacher’s help. On the back of it is a magnet. I’m going to take it to work with me. Also inside was a little plant that he planted in a little blue container. He told me that it’s a marigold plant and proceeded to overwater it. I just melted.

Typically at our house, we don’t do much for Mother’s Day or Father’s Day. When Nate asked me a few days ago what I wanted for Mother’s Day, I told him that something that he made would be great. What he gave me was just perfect, and I truly don’t want or expect anything from Frank. For one thing, I’m not his mother. Besides, I just don’t need a lot of presents.
_____________________________

I thought that would be the end of this post, but it seems that Mother’s Day just isn’t as simple as even what I wrote above. No, now I hear from Erin of Seriously? that NBC has deemed us adoptive mothers non-moms although now they’ve changed the category to “The Adopting Mom,” probably due to a plethora of complaints. My issue is that they had the category “The Non-Mom” to begin with and included adoptive mothers in that category at all.

Not cool, NBC, not cool at all.
_____________________________

Honestly? Even though I did absolutely melt with my son’s early Mother’s Day presents? — I still have this unease with these celebratory holidays that leave too many people out or that have the potential to cause too much hurt to too many people.

I remember many years after my father died how I felt on Father’s Day. Everyone was celebrating their fathers and I had no father to celebrate; it just seemed to magnify my loss. Even when Frank and I were married, neither of us had fathers to celebrate, so we just kind of said to each other, “Oh yeah, it’s Father’s Day. Hmmm . . . . . so, when did your father die?” Kind of morbid, no? It wasn’t until we adopted Nate six years ago that we were able to celebrate Father’s Day again.

I think the same thing about Valentine’s Day, about all of those people who don’t have someone and for whom their loneliness is magnified on a day like that.

For us, most of those days are pretty low-key just because that’s how we are and because that’s how we were raised. Since I’ve met mothers of loss — loss of various kinds — and children of loss of various kinds, the point has been driven home to me that Mother’s Day isn’t a happy day for a lot of women, for many children.
_____________________________

Did you know that the first proposal of any kind of Mother’s Day in the United States was by Julia Ward Howe?

It was a call to unite women against war. In 1870, she wrote the Mother’s Day Proclamation as a call for peace and disarmament. Howe failed in her attempt to get formal recognition of a Mother’s Day for Peace.
(Mother’s Day article)

Now, that kind of Mother’s Day I could get behind!

Tags:

Responses

I’m with you, and with Howe. That’s the right kind of Mother’s Day.

(Faxing Jeff Zucker gave me some satisfaction, more so than their change — though their response is on my blog if you’d like to read it. ).

I like pragmatic, R is totally pragmatic, and it’s grounding.

Re the Teleflora-NBC thing - they changed that gartuitously fast in my opinion. And if their letter is correct and their president is an AP, then shame on them for letting marketing drive their brains.

Thanks for a good post, and for that information about Julia Ward Howe.

Nighty-night!

Amen, to both you and to Howe. Puppy painted a flowerpot at daycare and planted a pansy in it for M Day. I love it and don’t need anything else. :)

Hello! You left a comment on my blog. Yes, I believe that I did email you previously when I was trying to learn more about ACS and Ha Tinh.

I have to admit that, while I understand and agree with your point, I’m currently all mushy with love for our soon-to-be daughter. I’m just over moon because we got new photos of her!

You and I are on the same frequency :) I already had Ms. Howe’s Mother’s Day Proclamation all set and in draft, ready to be published tomorrow.

Oh good, Theresa. The proclamation is beautiful. Yay you!!!

Well I hope you enjoy this Mother’s Day and celebrate it :) As a firstmother I wouldn’t want any different for you, but maybe that’s just because I think you’re wonderful.

And as for Valentine’s Day? I prefer to call it “Single’s Awareness Day.” Because believe me, if you’re single? There is NO day that you are more aware of it! haha

Wow, the NBC people wrote an apology. I know they would never have done that for a relinquishing mother - that doesn’t mean they shouldn’t have apologized to adoptive mothers, and I’m glad they did.

HAppy HAppiest mother’s day to you tomorrow Judes.

lots of love
Kim

Kim, you’re absolutely right. Of course, there wasn’t a space on their site for relinquishing mothers to begin with — always ignored, eh? — that’s not right either. Gah!

Thanks for the kind wishes. <3

I am with you and Ms. Howe. I wonder what we can do to push Mother’s Day back to a call for peace? We certainly need it more than breakfast in bed.

Leave a response

Your response:

Categories