Posted by: justenjoyhim | November 9, 2007

When absolutes ARE okay

Yes, I’ve been going on little — alrighty, and BIG — snarks a lot lately. It’s, as Tina so cleverly put it, because I’m eating Snarky Bunches of Oats cereal. Gotta love that stuff.

And I do believe, like I said in yesterday’s post, that people use absolutes way too much. Particularly when they introduce an opinion as a fact, such as “adoption is the WORST thing that can EVER happen to ANYONE in the world.”

Right, because war, pestilence, rape, murder, starvation, homelessness, losing your entire family, torture, or a combination of the aforementioned, are nothing compared to adoption. What is often needed, I believe, are “I” statements, as some of us (or so I’ve heard, *ahem*) learn in therapy. That is to say: “I feel that that adoption is the worst thing that has happened to me,” (I’m not speaking for myself, of course) OR “I believe that adoption can be a horrible thing with lifelong scars for many adoptees and natural mothers.”

However, there are times when absolutes are needed, are called for. Let’s face it, absolutes do serve a purpose. In the world of adoption, I think we (most of us, anyways) could agree that using an absolute is perfectly fine in the following sentence:

~ Adoptions should always be legal. (meaning, of course, if an adoption has any elements that are illegal, don’t pursue it).

Along the same basic thinking, using absolutes seems to work well when one is a parent. It doesn’t seem that saying the following would carry much weight with Junior:

It’s usually not best to go with strangers, Junior.

I mean, really. What child would understand that? “Well, Mom said it’s usually not good to go with strangers, but this one looks nice, plus he offered me candy AND a ride in his cool car! I bet he’s OK!!”

NO, of course not!! I tend to opt for the more emphatic, and from what I understand, police officers and other authoritative and safety types do also. So those types of sentences really are better with absolutes thrown into them:

NEVER EVER go with a stranger, whether the stranger is walking, bike-riding, on a motor-cycle, in a cool car, on a skate-board, on a scooter, on a hovercraft, in a boat, on a jet, in a rocket ship, on hoolies, or on anything. Just NEVER EVER go with a stranger.

NEVER EVER play with guns.

DO NOT play with matches. EVER.

I ALWAYS love you. I WILL ALWAYS love you. I am ALWAYS here for you.

ALWAYS tell Mommy she’s beautiful.

So, of course, there is room for absolutes in the English language. Just not as much room as many would have you believe. And not, I believe, where people are really trying to tell you what their opinion is and passing it off as . . . well, as an ABSOLUTE fact.

I mean, really. That, I KNOW is true. ALWAYS and FOREVER. ;)

Responses

This is great Judy. I’m trying to think of more absolutes, but I think you’ve got them all covered. Anyway, I really think living in the grey areas is much harder than living in black and white. But, sometimes there are black and whites that need to be held onto.

Tina

I thought (and this is not meant to be snarky) that if I’d presented something in my own blog, the ‘I feel’ was implied, which is why, when I leave notes and comments I do make more of a point to use the ‘I feel’ statements.

Tina ~ hey, thanks. There may be more absolutes and I know for a fact that there are more times when absolutes need to be used, but those are a good start.

GMA (which doesn’t stand for Good Morning America — hahaha, Oh, I amuse myself!) ~ hey, that makes sense. You write mostly about your own experience too. I’m trying to think of examples without being specific but don’t know if I can do that, but trust me, there are strong differences between your style of writing and someone else’s in which they would say something very general that states something like it’s a fact for everyone, not just him/herself. I don’t know if that makes a kind of vague sense, but I really do understand what you’re saying.

This is just me being exceedingly snarky at, oh, all kinds of posts by all kinds of people who make all kinds of generalizations that get me all kinds of cranky.

NEVER eat all of your kid’s Halloween candy in less than 48 hours.

Year after year, I keep forgetting this one.

“ANYONE would be better off dead than adopted.”

The first time I heard this one, it came from an adult adoptee, thirty-something and in grad school.

Fortunately, we don’t have Halloween in this part of the world, so there’s one absolute I don’t have to commit to memory, Paula O. (I’ll send a reminder out to family and friends in the US around the 29th next year.)

A big one for us, though, is NEVER go anywhere near the sea without Mom, Dad or Grandma right beside you. Very important when you live on an island.

With Sam turning five-years-old TODAY (How the heck did that come around so fast?), we’ll be spouting absolutes of love like crazy all day around here. I’ll keep my pouty “And you’ll NEVER be four again! Whaaaaaa!” to myself.

Leave a response

Your response:

Categories