Posted by: justenjoyhim | September 30, 2007

A-Men to that!!

If the desire to love someone by choice is a trend, it’s a trend I’d like to see continue.

Once again, Abebech nails it in Dear Ladies Of The View.

The ultimate goal is, of course, to keep families together. However, when those children who, yes, need families, are adopted into loving, ethical families who recognize and strive to learn about their issues of loss, then maybe, just MAYBE it’s time to pack judgment away. Perhaps the world at large can instead support this family As. A. Family. rather than cast aspersions on them like people such as Sherri Shepard do, without knowing so much as one thing about Mary Louise Parker’s motivations in adopting her new daughter from Ethiopia or, I’m assuming, knowing Parker’s daughter’s circumstances.

Yes, that does go for other adoptive families with the same traits — loving, ethical, learning about issues of loss — too. It could help to also remember that, as a very wise woman said to me, most people are really doing their best. I would think that helping, supporting, and gently educating them would go miles further than scolding and beating them down would.

At any rate, thank you, Abebech. Bravo to you!!

Responses

I too agree. I hate when they say that adoption is a trend - I don’t see how that is a trend. Installing a new pool in your backyard b/c your neighbors do, that might be a trend. Wearing all black in middle school, that might be a trend. BUT changing your entire life for a child - NOT a trend.

I didn’t see this View, but I will go back on my TIVO and find it.

I don’t entirely agree but you are still my pal!

I should’ve been clearer (I was too busy being a tad obnoxious): Shephard was actually commenting on Paris Hilton’s planned trip to Africa — which had nothing to do with adoption — but used that moment to comment particularly about white women adopting black children.

Like you, Judy, I don’t shy away from the ethical questions about adoption and transracial, transnational adoption in particular (and have made my share of aparents and paparents mad along the way — couldn’t believe the number of links/hits from my fifth best option post and the discussion outside of my blog) but I also can’t stand mass media offhand offense to adopted children. My daughter is free to disagree with our decision to adopt her, across racial and national borders, but I never want her to think (or someone else to think about her) that we entered into it _lightly_ or that she is somehow not valuable and valued.

I gave the example of Samantha Bee’s clip, but I’d say too that ibastard’s t-shirt generator was incredibly funny in that painful way, and it made people think, and it targeted the appropriate targets (aparents and paparents, who are the ones in the power position). Shephard’s comment, not so funny, and no opportunity for real, intelligent discourse. To be fair she does say she’s only now getting around to intelligent conversation . . .

Thanks for your encouragement, Judy. You’re fantastic.

No problem, Kim — and that’s what I like, that we can disagree but still be respectful and still be pals!!

Abebech, I understand and I hope I didn’t put words into your mouth that shouldn’t have been there. I just don’t like the knee-jerk reactions that media particularly have when people (especially famous people) adopt internationally, particularly children of another race.

I also thought iBastard’s t-shirts were, as you say perfectly, “incredibly funny in that painful way.”

I guess what it comes down to is motivation and the thing is, most people outside of the immediate circumstance don’t know the motivations of the person/people adopting said children. Now, some adoptions do come into question, and some I myself have questions about. I used to voice those questions; I try not to now just because I really don’t know the whole story.

And you know, what it always boils down to, time and time again is that it’s always so damn complicated. Each situation is different, each story is different, each adoption is different.

Makes my head hurt.

No, not at all! I was just adding nuance to my own nuance-lacking letter :)

Dreaming — Yes, and I do like Abebech’s point that people should always consider: what if the children hear themselves talked about that way? How are they going to feel??

Leave a response

Your response:

Categories